THIS BLOG HAS MOVED

Please join us at snowcoveredhills.com.

Get the posts on my new blog by e-mail. Enter your e-mail address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

New posts on snowcoveredhills.com:

Saturday, June 23, 2007

Sicko

A relative e-mailed me a newspaper story about Michael Moore's latest movie. I'm a bit out of the popular-culture loop up here and haven't seen it, but I do know that Mr. Moore has rose-coloured glasses where Canada is concerned. He's also a bit too quick to jump to conclusions about our society. I will offer a quick overview of our health system, in case he leaves out some details:

  • Doctor's visits (including specialists): FREE, sort of. The government is now taking $1500 out of my paycheque every two weeks. I go to the doctor maybe three times a year.
  • Hospital visits: FREE, sort of. See above. We do not pay the cost of any medical procedure that is done in a hospital.
  • Medical supplies, including medicine: PATIENT PAYS FULL PRICE. Steve's diabetic pump cost $5000, and his blood-testing strips cost $1 each. A person I used to work with is taking pills that cost $100 a day. You can buy medical insurance to cover all or most of these costs.
  • Ambulance trips: PATIENT PAYS FULL PRICE. About $300 per trip, at least here in Name of Town Withheld. This is a good deal, as it gets you four handsome and sympathetic ambulance attendants at your door in about five minutes.
  • Wait times: ABYSMAL. A friend of mine (full disclosure: who has nothing but good things to say about our system) almost died from a weird pregnancy illness that caused severe vomiting. She spent a LOT of time in emergency wait rooms, often next to people with severe alcoholism and mental illnesses. You can imagine how great this was for her.
  • Freedom to choose your doctor: NOT TRUE. When your doctor leaves town, you have to beg another GP to see you, and most will not even consider it. It has been over a year since I had a doctor. Steve convinced a GP to be his doctor about six months ago, and we are hoping that she will agree to treat Michael and me. However, it is true that we do not have HMOs that assign doctors to patients or demand that you cycle through cheaper treatments before trying treatments that are more expensive.
  • Satisfaction with Canadian health-care system: MIXED. The first thing any Canadian will say about our system is that it is better than the American one. You will usually get this from people who have no experience with the American system, so you can judge for yourself how much their opinions are worth.
Our system is a source of national pride, which is so Canadian I could vomit. Only in Canada would a mandatory group-insurance plan be a source of national pride.

3 comments:

Torq said...

Mike Moore is a dufus (this, by the way, is my new term for someone who is both really vain and not very intelligent, yet still thinks that they are). I have actually been spent a nauseatingly large amount of time either being forced to watch his videos or talking about him, by people who are convinced that he is the cleverest man on the planet.

I am not sure what they have but sincerely hope it is not contagious.

Steve & Megan said...

I've seen the new movie. Well, most of it. I should probably post a response, because in true Michael Moore style, there are a number of implied errors.

This, of course, is his M.O. and the reason I get really mad about his stuff. Some people think he makes documentaries, but his films are pure propaganda. That doesn't need to be a bad thing unless, like him, you pass your work off as a documentary.

The important thing to remember when watching his films is that while each sentence is usually technically accurate, it could be strung together with other sentences or matched with images that make you come away with a completely wrong idea. Facts that don't match his storyline are ignored. Images that would help you understand how something happened are completely removed.

Torq said...

I think that I would have made a first rate propagandist if I had been properly inclined. I am sure that I would not only be a great deal richer but famous too!

The price would be having to live with my monsterous hypocricy and I am not sure I could do that. Now I CAN invent a moral system that allows me to not only to be a propagandist but tells me that this is the RIGHT thing to do!